Tuesday, 25 November 2014

Analects 1:4

In this particular day I shall interpret a verse from the Analects, namely 1:4. In A Source Book In Chinese Philosophy, Wing Tsit Chan presents the verse:

“ Tseng-Tzu said, ‘ Every day I examine myself on three points: whether in counseling others I have not been loyal; whether in intercourse with my friends I have not been faithful; and whether I have not repeated again and again and practiced the instructions of my teacher.’ ” 1

Firstly, let us discuss the theme of the verse. This verse depicts the value of “chung” or “conscientiousness”.   Conscientiousness can be understood as being aware of one’s self, in all of one’s actions, words, and deeds.   It depicts one’s thoughtfulness to others.   This thoughtfulness is governed by the principles of right and wrong that the individual holds, which is crucial in developing his character and promoting harmony.  

In this second point, the theme shall be applied with the three points that Tseng-Tzu stated from the verse.

‘ whether in counseling others I have not been loyal; whether in intercourse with my friends I have not been faithful; and whether I have not repeated again and again and practiced the instructions of my teacher.’

Let us discuss the first two points in the verse. These points share the same aspect of the “chung” (conscientiousness) being applied in the social sense.   Conscientiousness, in this case, can be applied in the concept of motive.   If one’s motive is inclined to goodness, then the action of the individual is justified.   It is an application of the “chung”.   But if it is otherwise, then the action done by the individual is negated.   This in turn will breed disharmony. It could destroy one’s relationship with another and everything around him.

Let us apply this in the first point, which concerns on counseling.    If one gives advice for the purpose of helping him without any ulterior motive, then the act justifies the value of “chung”.   Say, a person gives counseling to a friend who is currently having problems with his business.   If the one who is counseling gives advice so that his friend may be able to solve his problem, then the act is justified and thus promotes harmony.   However, if the one who is counseling gives the help so that he can use it as a means of abusing his friend, his act is negated.   This is because the action is not an application of the “chung”, for the action is not grounded on the principles of goodness.    The act negates itself for the motive does not fully demonstrate the benevolence of the action. This causes disharmony.

Now let us apply the concept of “chung” in the last point. 

‘and whether I have not repeated again and again and practiced the instructions of my teacher.’

In this point, the concept of conscientiousness is applied in the individual sense.  This is more focused on actualizing the lessons learned along the way. 

This emphasizes the idea of not merely being intelligent or being able to explain the different philosophical concepts of benevolence and goodness.    It gives the primacy on actualizing these ideas in the life of the person himself, so that he cultivates himself.   This actualization can only be done when the person holds moral principles in deciding on his acts.   

For example, most of us learn something about our religion by formal study in schools and by practices rooted from the family.   We can explain to people who do not know the doctrines, dogmas, ceremonies, rituals, values and beliefs of our religion because of formal study and practice.   But simply knowing the facts about one’s religion does not make one truly religious.  He must practice what he believes.  For example, he can practice impartial judgment of others or he can be sincere in one’s work.   It is in these ways that he justifies the religious values and all the other things related to his faith.    And this action is a manifestation of harmony, which is rooted from conscientiousness.   

Another significant point is something related to the phrase ‘practiced the instructions of my teacher’.
This phrase represents the common mistake among all disciples and students who journey towards learning.   They take the knowledge they receive for granted, and eventually forgetting about them as they finished going over it.   This act negates the essence of learning itself.   Learning is supposed to be aimed at gradually developing the whole being of an individual into goodness by active and intellectual participation.   And goodness is rooted again from conscientiousness.  

 An individual that is inactive in the intellectual participation depicts the opposite of conscientiousness.   This is because he does not think of the effort of his teacher in sacrificing time and energy in teaching his lessons.  This ignorance is the reason why some students or disciples fail to practice their teacher’s lessons.    If the student only develops thoughtfulness in him by recognizing the sacrifices of his teacher, then he can surely practice what his teacher taught him.  He can even appreciate the lessons all the more, and even generate a deeper understanding of it.  

Eventually, he becomes a catalyst of harmony in home and in society through these realizations.

This last point discusses “chung” (conscientiousness) as an expression of “jen” (goodness).    Conscientiousness is an expression of goodness, for being thoughtful or being mindful of right and wrong can lead one into choosing the right action.  This is because it gives one a wider scope in situations.   Because one sees the bigger picture, one can have a clearer idea about what is an appropriate action in relation to the situation at hand.        


Every person is inherently good. This inherent goodness is essentially expressed in the “chung” or conscientiousness.  It teaches one the courage to be consistently good.  It also emphasizes thoughtfulness to others and being mindful of strengthening one’s values associated with good and harmony.    One should develop good motives and “others-oriented” purposes.    By developing the value of conscientiousness, goodness grows within the individual.  It is through this manner that he becomes a noble man, worthy of emulation and respect. 

Sources:
1. Wing Tsit Chan, “The Humanism of Confucius”, (United States: Princeton University Press, 1963), In A Source Book In Chinese Philosophy, 24.

No comments:

Post a Comment