Friday, 5 December 2014

Analects 19:6

In this particular day I shall interpret a verse from the Analects, namely 19:6. In A Source Book In Chinese Philosophy, Wing Tsit Chan presents the verse:

“Tzu-hsia said, ‘To study extensively, to be steadfast in one’s purpose, to inquire earnestly, and to reflect on what is at hand (that is, what one can put into practice) – humanity consists in these.’” 1

 The theme revolves around the concept of “making the will sincere” which is the essence of humanity.  Making the will sincere connotes zeroing in on four elements of humanity:  extensive study, steadfast purpose, earnest questioning and reflection.   Sincerity of the will is an essential guide of moral living.   

 What does “to study extensively” mean?  This means that every person exists along with various realities in life. These realities are either positive or negative.  They can be very challenging and innovating. Thus, for a person to connect with them rightly, he has to examine them thoroughly by being objective, broad-minded and determined.  By these, he will have clear bases in doing something.

He needs to “study” the situation at hand.  This means that he must look at the different angles and weigh the two sides of the situation.   This situation analysis must not be done properly.  One must do this in a very objective and open-minded way so that one will not lose his way towards a well-informed decision.   For example, a person attempts to resolve the personal conflict between his two friends.  Just simply taking sides would not help resolve the matter rather it would only worsen the situation.   The right thing for the individual to do is “study” the situation at hand.  He must listen to both sides and weigh the reasons of the two.  Because he weighed the situation carefully and extensively, it led him to resolve the conflict between his two friends without hurting or losing either of them.  It is because of his “extensive study” of the situation that he acted accordingly.   It is in this way that the first step of making the will sincere is attained. After settling the matter and having some sort of a “plan” that was made after “studying” the situation, the individual needs to maintain the knowledge he gained.

 Moreover, “to be steadfast in one’s purpose” means relating the knowledge gained from extensive examination or study of a situation or reality to a purpose.   Like the example I gave on resolving conflict of two friends, I connect it to the purpose of real friendship, which is facilitating peace between friends in situation which is quite not peaceful.  This act implies inner and real concern for the two friends in conflict.  The purpose of friendship is to build relation not division, to propagate peace and not discord and to strengthen harmony among fellow human beings.

To “inquire earnestly “ means to evaluate the impact or effectiveness of an act or decision based on the given situation.  An individual who is sincere applies tact and moral wit in every situation he encounters and in every act he does.  It must be noted that whether actions are good or not so good, they are open to criticisms.  The criticisms revolve primarily on the impact or effectiveness of a deed or an action.  What the individual needs to do at this point is to deal with these criticisms.  The way on how the individual deals with it is crucial in making his will sincere.  This is because if he is really authentic and sincere in what he does,   he can deal with criticisms properly and objectively without taking them against him.  Criticisms give him best inputs to recognize his self and to improve more.  He is humble enough to learn more and improve more.     

This gives the idea that being sincere in one’s intention is not something that is attained easily.  It is something to work hard for with the help of others.  That is what questioning is for.  To question is to get answers from something in which you lack.  It is in this humble act that one learns to grow and improve his self.  Another way of seeing this phrase is that one must constantly be thinking and doing.  Objective and right inquiry makes the mind awake; thus, it makes the person aware of what he does  and how he does things. It must be noted that all his actions and decisions should be with purpose and aligned with such purpose.

 Further, the individual must have sufficient time to reflect on new learning out of all experiences and decisions he made.  This is what the phrase “to reflect on what is at hand” implies.   Reflection is necessary in developing sincerity in one’s self because it makes one see the bigger picture of every reality he encounters in life.   It also develops one’s thoughtfulness or deep concern to his fellow human beings through appropriate actions, decisions and intentions.  Reflection aids in making a person’s will sincere for it gives him a concrete opportunity to show thoughtfulness and compassion to his fellow human beings. This thoughtfulness or concern and compassion for others are the very elements of social harmony.


 To be human is a matter of  knowing what one is, where he is , what he is for and how he is living with others.  It requires well-directed knowledge, clear and good intention or purpose and a deep concern for the good of others.  This is what is called “human-heartedness.”   The gifts that each one has are a mix of right thought, right intention or purpose, right inquiry and right reflection.  In these, the true meaning of humanity rests.

Source:
1.  Wing Tsit Chan, “The Humanism of Confucius”, (United States: Princeton University Press, 1963), In A Source Book In Chinese Philosophy,38.

No comments:

Post a Comment